Web Application Architecture - Tips on Maintaining HTTPContext in Presentation Layer


The majority of the Application Architecture advice seems to advise strongly that only Presentation Layer should have access to HTTPContext (to promote loose coupling, decrease dependencies, increase testability etc).

So, how do people deal with Caching and Session? Very specific DataAccess and Business Logic knowledge is required to determine what items need caching to best benefit application performance. However, and an ASP.Net web application, access to these is provided via the HTTPContext.

One option would be to create a CacheFactory and a SessionFactory, and an ICache and ISession interface - and then somehow use DI principle to pass and ISession and ICache to each method in the BLL and subsequently DA Layer that needs it.

Is this really what developers end up doing? Is there another, easier, way to deal with this?

Thanks for any advice.

Personally, if I'm developing for ASP.NET (web) only, and I know the class libraries are only going to target the web, I have no issues referencing System.Web or any other assembly as needed. Sometimes practicality should come first.

On the other hand if you know, or are unsure if the BLL, DAL or other layers may be reused in a client-server or other environment, you may need to look at using a more flexible approach such as a session handler interface, etc.

The main thing is you clearly understand what best practice recommends. At that point you can make rational decisions about what should apply to each project or situation. It won't always fit like a glove.