Need help with the behavior of COM with TPL

advertisements

I need some help understanding the difference between STA and MTA with respect to the winform and console application. I am using a third party COM interface to execute functions in parallel, using parallel.invoke. When i do this in console application everything works fine and code actually runs in parallel. But when i do the same thing in Winform it's sequential, and if i remove the STAtrhread tag above the entry point of winform , it start to work fine in parallel. Can anyone explain this behavior?,Any suggestions would be nice!


COM has a feature that's entirely missing in .NET. A COM class can specify whether it is thread-safe or not. It does so with a key in the registry named ThreadingModel. Just like most .NET classes, the vast majority of COM classes are not thread-safe so they specify "Apartment". Which is a somewhat obscure term that implies "only call me from the thread on which I was created". Which automatically provides thread-safety.

To make that work, a thread that creates COM objects has to indicate what kind of support it is willing to provide for COM classes that are not thread safe. An STA thread is a safe home. Requirement is that the thread pumps a message loop, like any UI thread does. The message loop is the mechanism by which COM marshals a call from a worker thread to the thread that created the object. A thread that joins the MTA specifically says it does not provide support.

COM has to do something about MTA threads, they are not suitable for COM objects that are not thread safe. It creates a new thread, an STA thread to give the COM object a safe home. That's quite inefficient, every method call has to be marshaled. And risky, a COM class may still be thread-unsafe if its objects share state internally.

So what's happening in your Winforms case is that you created all the objects on the main thread, which is an STA. And make calls from parallel worker threads, those calls all get marshaled and serialized back to the STA thread. Inevitably, they execute one-by-one and you get no concurrency.

In your Console case, you created them on an MTA thread. So COM is forced to create threads for each object. The method calls on your worker threads are still marshaled, but now to multiple threads. So now you do get concurrency, at the cost of significant overhead, a bunch of extra threads. And the risk of failure when the server shares state internally.

Make the Winforms case the same as the Console case by creating the COM objects on a worker thread. Do test it very thoroughly.