CSV analysis: how can NSScanner recognize the empty field (that is,)?


I am very new to Xcode and trying - as millions - to parse a CSV file. I have read many contributions and I am managing it but I have a problem when my NSScanner intercepts an empty field: "Field_A, Field_B,, Field_D". I guess it is because it ignores empty space by default, or in this case no space at all.

String is:


I tried to debug it using scanLocation:

2011-04-22 15:57:32.414 Spending[42015:a0f] Before while...scan location is:0
2011-04-22 15:57:32.414 Spending[42015:a0f] Account: "Personal" - scan location is:10
2011-04-22 15:57:32.415 Spending[42015:a0f] Date: "2011-01-01" - scan location is:23
2011-04-22 15:57:32.415 Spending[42015:a0f] Category: "Personal" - scan location is:34
2011-04-22 15:57:32.416 Spending[42015:a0f] Subcategory: "Cigarettes" - scan location is:47
2011-04-22 15:57:32.416 Spending[42015:a0f] Income: 4.600000 - scan location is:53
2011-04-22 15:57:32.416 Spending[42015:a0f] Expense: 0.000000 - scan location is:53
2011-04-22 15:57:32.417 Spending[42015:a0f] Payment: "Cash" - scan location is:60
2011-04-22 15:57:32.417 Spending[42015:a0f] Note: "" - scan location is:63

And as you can see after that even expense field gets no value (should be 4.60).

Here is the relevant piece of code:

NSScanner *scanner = [NSScanner scannerWithString:fileString];
    [scanner setCharactersToBeSkipped: [NSCharacterSet characterSetWithCharactersInString:@"\n, "]];

    NSString *account, *date, *category, *subcategory, *payment, *note;
    float income, expense;

    // Set up data delimiter using comma
    NSCharacterSet *commaSet;
    commaSet = [NSCharacterSet characterSetWithCharactersInString:@","];

    NSLog (@"Before while...scan location is:%d\n", scanner.scanLocation);

    [scanner scanUpToCharactersFromSet:commaSet intoString:&account];
    NSLog(@"Account: %@ - scan location is:%d\n",account, scanner.scanLocation);

    [scanner scanUpToCharactersFromSet:commaSet intoString:&date];
    NSLog(@"Date: %@ - scan location is:%d\n",date, scanner.scanLocation);

    [scanner scanUpToCharactersFromSet:commaSet intoString:&category];
    NSLog(@"Category: %@ - scan location is:%d\n",category, scanner.scanLocation);

    [scanner scanUpToCharactersFromSet:commaSet intoString:&subcategory];
    NSLog(@"Subcategory: %@ - scan location is:%d\n",subcategory, scanner.scanLocation);

    [scanner scanFloat:&income];
    NSLog(@"Income: %f - scan location is:%d\n",income, scanner.scanLocation);

    [scanner scanFloat:&expense];
    NSLog(@"Expense: %f - scan location is:%d\n",expense, scanner.scanLocation);

    [scanner scanUpToCharactersFromSet:commaSet intoString:&payment];
    NSLog(@"Payment: %@ - scan location is:%d\n",payment, scanner.scanLocation);

    [scanner scanUpToCharactersFromSet:commaSet intoString:&note];
    NSLog(@"Note: %@\n - scan location is:%d",note, scanner.scanLocation);

I tried looking carefully through NSScanner Class Reference, but could not get an idea? Do you have any?

Thanks, Fabrizio.

The reason why the scanner doesn't see your empty field is because you told it to skip commas. You called setCharactersToBeSkipped with a set of 3 characters:

  1. '\n' The newline character
  2. ',' Comma
  3. ' ' Space

When you then ask the scanner to "scanFloat", it goes over any skippable character until it reaches a decimal number. This is how the empty field gets skipped.

If you want to catch empty fields, remove the comma from your set of characters to skip. Then, any time a scan function find an empty field, it will return NO. You might have to increment the scanning position manually when this happens.